Best Pizza in New York
77 restaurants compared
Top 5 Pizza in New York (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 77 restaurants:
- Chrissy's Pizza, $30.00 (Greenpoint)
- Mama's TOO! — 99% recommended, $6.50 (Upper West Side)
- Di Fara Pizza — 99% recommended, $6.00 (Midwood)
- Rubirosa — 99% recommended, $33.00 (SoHo)
- L'Industrie Pizza — 99% recommended, $7.50 (Williamsburg)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 77 Restaurants Compared
Chrissy's Pizza
Vegan Red
$30.00
16-inch whole-pie vegan option with red sauce, olive oil, and fresh oregano.
Mama's TOO!
Cacio e Pepe Square
$6.50
Thick square slice with pecorino, mozzarella, and a heavy hand of black pepper.
Di Fara Pizza
Regular Slice
$6.00
Thin-crust round slice with a three-cheese blend and hand-snipped fresh basil.
Rubirosa
Tie-Dye Pizza
$33.00
Thin-crust pie with vodka sauce, tomato sauce, and a pesto swirl.
L'Industrie Pizza
Burrata Slice
$7.50
Margherita slice topped with a whole glob of fresh burrata and basil oil.
Denino's Pizzeria
Cheese Pie
$30.80
Large 16-inch thin-crust pie with aged mozzarella and a savory tomato sauce.
Zero Otto Nove
La Riccardo Pizza
$22.00
Unique white pie with butternut squash purée, smoked mozzarella, and spicy pancetta.
Paulie Gee's Slice Shop
Hellboy Square Slice
$5.50
Thick-cut pepperoni square slice finished with Mike's Hot Honey.
Joe & Pat's
Vodka Pie
$24.00
The signature wafer-thin pie topped with rich vodka sauce, mozzarella, and fresh basil.
John's of Bleecker St.
John's Original Pizza
$25.00
Thin-crust coal-oven pie with aged mozzarella and a rich tomato sauce.
Totonno's
Coal-Oven Cheese Pie
$28.00
Large thin-crust pie with fresh mozzarella and a rich, smoky tomato sauce.
Roberta's
Bee Sting Pizza
$26.00
Tomato sauce, mozzarella, spicy salami, chili, and a finishing drizzle of honey.
Joe's Pizza (Greenwich Village)
Cheese Slice
$4.50
Classic New York plain cheese slice with a thin, foldable crust.
Lucali
Margherita Pizza
$30.00
A thin-crust, wood-fired pie with a secret three-cheese blend and fresh basil.
Paulie Gee's
Hellboy Pizza
$24.00
Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, spicy salami, and a finishing drizzle of Mike's Hot Honey.
Denino's Pizzeria
The Garbage Pie
$38.00
Cheese pie loaded with sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, mushrooms, and onions.
Scarr's Pizza
Regular Slice
$4.50
Standard New York cheese slice with house-milled flour crust.
Mama's TOO!
Angry Maria Square
$6.50
Spicy square slice with tomato sauce, mozzarella, hot chili oil, and hot honey.
Joe & Pat's
Cheese Pie
$19.50
Classic large thin-crust cheese pie with a savory tomato sauce.
Joe's Pizza (Greenwich Village)
Pepperoni Slice
$5.50
Classic cheese slice topped with traditional New York pepperoni.
Paulie Gee's Slice Shop
The Freddy Prince
$5.50
Upside-down square slice with fresh mozzarella under the sauce and sesame seeds on the bottom.
Di Fara Pizza
Square Slice
$8.00
Thick-cut Sicilian-style slice with caramelized cheese edges and rich tomato sauce.
Paulie Gee's
Vegan Red, White & Greenhouse
$23.00
Vegan red sauce pie with house-made cashew ricotta and baby arugula.
Totonno's
White Pie
$30.00
Smoky thin-crust pie with mozzarella, garlic, and fresh herbs.
Una Pizza Napoletana
Marinara
$25.00
San Marzano tomatoes, wild oregano, garlic, basil, and olive oil on thin crust.
Mario's
Pizza Margherita
$20.00
Thin-crust Neapolitan-style pizza with fresh tomato sauce and mozzarella.
Prince Street Pizza
Spicy Spring
$6.00
Pepperoni square with crisp, cupped edges and pools of rendered fat.
50 Kalò
Margherita
$14.00
Tomato, mozzarella di bufala, basil, and extra virgin olive oil on super-hydrated dough.
John's of Bleecker St.
The Sasso Pizza
$28.00
John's Original topped with aged Parmigiano, oregano, and black pepper.
Roberta's
Famous Original Pizza
$22.00
Tomato sauce, mozzarella, caciocavallo, oregano, and chili flakes.
Emily (West Village)
The Emily Pizza
$26.00
White pie with mozzarella, pistachios, honey, and truffle oil.
Emily (West Village)
The Colony Pizza
$24.00
Tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, pickled jalapeños, and honey.
Paulie Gee's
The Greenpointer
$22.00
Fresh mozzarella, lemon-scented arugula, and shaved Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Paulie Gee's Slice Shop
Vegan Hellboy Square
$6.00
Vegan pepperoni square with house-made vegan cheese and hot honey.
B Side
Killer Bee Pizza
$24.00
Wood-fired pizza with house marinara, mozzarella, sopressata, garlic puree, chili oil, and honey drizzle.
Lombardi's
Original Margherita
$22.00
Classic pizza with San Marzano tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, and olive oil.
Una Pizza Napoletana
Margherita
$25.00
San Marzano tomatoes, buffalo mozzarella DOP, basil, and olive oil.
Chrissy's Pizza
Pepperoni
$34.00
16-inch pie topped with thick, crispy pepperoni cups filled with neon orange oil.
Roberta's
Speckenwolf Pizza
$24.00
Mozzarella, speck, mushrooms, onions, and oregano.
John's of Bleecker St.
The Margherita
$28.00
Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and plenty of fresh basil.
Joe's Pizza (Greenwich Village)
Fresh Mozzarella Slice
$6.00
Thin-crust slice topped with rounds of fresh mozzarella and basil.
Paulie Gee's Slice Shop
Mootz Round Slice
$4.50
Traditional thin-crust cheese slice with a high-quality mozzarella blend.
Mama's TOO!
House Special Square
$7.50
A rotating seasonal square often featuring ingredients like stracciatella or mortadella.
Di Fara Pizza
The Artichoke Pie
$38.00
White pie with mozzarella, parmesan, and fresh baby artichoke hearts.
Denino's Pizzeria
Clam Pie
$34.00
White pie with fresh chopped clams, garlic, and mozzarella.
Prince Street Pizza
Prince Perfection
$5.00
Square slice with mozzarella and sauce atop the cheese (upside-down style).
B Side
Carbonara Pizza
$23.00
Wood-fired pizza with fontina, mozzarella, pancetta, panna cream, parmesan, black pepper, and egg.
Mario's of Arthur Avenue
Pizza Margherita
$20.00
Wood-fired Neapolitan pizza with tomato, mozzarella, basil, and olive oil.
L'Industrie Pizza
The New Yorker
$6.50
Pepperoni, sausage, onions, peppers, and sesame seeds on the crust.
Prince Street Pizza
Pepperoni Sicilian Square
$5.00
Classic thick Sicilian square with quality pepperoni.
Scarr's Pizza
Hot Honey Pepperoni Square
$6.50
Thick-cut Sicilian-style square slice with pepperoni and hot honey.
50 Kalò
Black Pork Salami & Squash Blossoms
$18.00
Pizza topped with Caserta black pork salami, squash blossoms, and basil.
Paulie Gee's
Cherry Jones
$24.00
Fresh mozzarella, gorgonzola, dried cherries, and orange blossom honey.
Mama's TOO!
Poached Pear Square
$7.00
Unique square slice with poached pears, gorgonzola, and walnuts.
Emmy Squared
Colony Pizza
$19.00
Mozzarella, cupping pepperoni, pickled jalapeños, and honey drizzle on Detroit-style crust.
50 Kalò
Friarielli & Sausage
$17.00
Calabrian sausage with friarielli (Italian broccoli rabe) and garlic.
Lucky Charlie
Pepperoni Pizza
$36.00
Coal-fired pizza with imported pepperoni and fresh mozzarella.
Chrissy's Pizza
Plain
$30.00
16-inch cheese pizza with fresh mozzarella, sweet tangy sauce, and grated parmesan.
Saraghina
Margherita Pizza
$18.00
Wood-fired Neapolitan pizza with fresh mozzarella, basil, and tomato.
50 Kalò
Bufala & Rucola
$16.00
Fresh mozzarella di bufala with wild arugula dressed in olive oil and lemon.
Emmy Squared
Emmy Pizza (White Pizza)
$19.00
Fluffy ricotta, sharp pecorino, creamy Havarti, and cilantro-mint ranch on Detroit-style crust.
Slicehaus
Potato and Bacon Slice
$5.00
New York slice with gently roasted potatoes, bacon, and rosemary.
Emmy Squared
Pepperoni Pizza
$18.00
Mozzarella, Ezzo cupping pepperoni, and tomato sauce on Detroit-style crust.
Lombardi's
Clam Pizza
$26.00
Coal-oven pizza with littleneck clams, olive oil, garlic, and romano cheese.
Una Pizza Napoletana
Bianca
$25.00
Buffalo mozzarella, garlic, basil, and olive oil without tomato sauce.
Una Pizza Napoletana
Margherita with Hot Peppers
$27.00
Classic Margherita topped with spicy peperoncino peppers.
Emmy Squared
Vodka Pizza
$18.00
House-made vodka sauce, mozzarella, and sharp pecorino on Detroit-style crust.
B Side
Marge Pizza
$18.00
Wood-fired pizza with house marinara, fresh mozzarella, basil, oregano, and sea salt.
Prince Street Pizza
Spicy Vodka Sicilian Square
$5.50
Sicilian square with creamy vodka sauce, aromatically spiced.
Slicehaus
Margherita Slice
$4.50
Classic tomato, mozzarella, and basil on 48-hour fermented dough.
Lombardi's
Meatball & Ricotta Red Pie
$25.00
Pizza with housemade meatballs, ricotta, tomato sauce, and mozzarella.
B Side
Shrimp Scampi Pizza
$26.00
Wood-fired pizza topped with shrimp, garlic, white wine reduction, and fresh parsley.
Una Pizza Napoletana
Filetti
$26.00
Cherry tomatoes, buffalo mozzarella, garlic, basil, and olive oil.
Prince Street Pizza
Plain Sicilian Square
$4.00
No-topping Sicilian square letting the dough and sauce shine.
Slicehaus
Robiola and Prosciutto Slice
$6.00
Creamy Robiola cheese and prosciutto on 48-hour fermented dough.
Lombardi's
White Ricotta Pizza
$24.00
Pizza with ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, and herbs—no sauce.
Lucky Charlie
Red Pizza with Sicilian Anchovies
$28.00
Coal-fired pizza topped with red sauce, anchovies, and Italian herbs.