The most famous pizza slice in the world. The crust is thin, lacy, and has a perfect 'fold' without breaking. It's topped with a bright, well-balanced tomato sauce and a layer of mozzarella that is salty and oily in exactly the right proportions. It is a brilliant example of consistency—it tastes the same today as it did 40 years ago. Reviewers consistently name it as the benchmark for judgeing all other New York pizza. Pete Wells has highlighted it as a city essential.
Tips from diners
Get the plain cheese slice. Don't ruin the balance with toppings. It's the best way to taste the quality of the sauce and the dough. Fold it lengthwise and eat it standing up.
A textbook pepperoni slice. Thin, salty pepperoni rounds are added to the cheese base, releasing their savory oils during the bake. The crust maintains its structural integrity despite the extra weight and grease. It is a favorite for those wanting a bit more savory-salty punch than the plain version. Reviewers praise the lack of 'pepperoni flop.'
Tips from diners
The pepperoni is traditional—large and thin. It provides a great salty kick. Make sure to use a few extra napkins for the oil—it's part of the Joe's charm.
A slightly more 'refined' option than the standard aged-mozzarella slice. It features creamy rounds of fresh mozzarella and fresh basil leaves added before the final bake. The sauce is the same bright tomato base, resulting in a cleaner, lighter flavor profile that showcases the quality of the cheese. Reviewers often cite it as the best 'upscale' slice at the shop.
Founded by Joe Pozzuoli, Joe's Pizza is a foundational pillar of New York City culture. While it has expanded to other locations, the original on Carmine Street remains the heart of the legend. It is famous for resisting all trends—no fancy toppings, no gourmet dough—just high-quality, consistent slices that have fed everyone from local students to global celebrities for nearly 50 years. It is widely cited as the 'gold standard' for the New York street slice.
The line can look intimidating, often stretching out onto Carmine Street, but it moves incredibly fast. The counter staff are legendary for their speed. You'll usually have your slice in under 5 minutes.
There are no chairs. You eat at the small counters or leaning against the wall outside. It is a high-energy, 'in and out' spot. If you want a sit-down meal, this isn't it.
Joe's is open until 4 AM or 5 AM every night. It is the ultimate late-night fuel source in the Village. The energy at 3 AM on a Saturday is some of the best people-watching in the city.
Page last updated: