The quintessential coal-oven pie. The crust is paper-thin and remarkably smoky with a slight char, achieved only by the intense heat of the coal fire. It's topped with a savory, concentrated tomato sauce and high-quality aged mozzarella that browns beautifully. It is widely cited as the platonic ideal of a New York whole pie. Reviewers consistently praise the lack of 'flop' despite the thinness.
Tips from diners
Don't over-top this pie. The beauty is in the crust and the char. A simple pepperoni or sausage addition is fine, but too many vegetables will make it soggy.
A nod to the founder's preferred way of eating pizza. This pie takes the original base and adds layers of sharp, salty Parmigiano-Reggiano, plenty of aromatic oregano, and a heavy hand of black pepper before baking. The result is a more intense, savory flavor profile that highlights the smokiness of the coal oven.
Tips from diners
This is much more flavorful than the regular pie if you like a sharp, peppery kick. It pairs perfectly with their house red wine.
A lighter and more vibrant alternative to the aged-cheese original. It features large rounds of fresh buffalo mozzarella and a mountain of fresh basil added right after the pie leaves the oven. The sauce is slightly sweeter and brighter, offering a cleaner taste profile that showcases the quality of the raw ingredients.
John's of Bleecker Street is one of the few remaining authentic coal-oven pizzerias in New York City. Founded by John Sasso, it has resisted almost every modern trend—no slices, no reservations, no delivery. The interior is famously covered in decades of carved initials and graffiti, and the ovens produce a uniquely thin, smoky crust that is the benchmark for the New York coal-oven style.
There is NO SLICES. This is a common mistake for tourists. You must order a whole pie. The line moves fast, but expect to wait 30-45 minutes on weekends.
John's is strictly cash only. There is an ATM inside, but it's better to hit your own bank before you join the line to avoid the extra fee.
The booths are tight and authentic. If you're a large group (6+), call ahead to see if they can accommodate you, otherwise you'll be waiting a very long time for two booths next to each other.
Page last updated: