Best Dishes at Paulie Gee's
The Mootz
PizzaCheesy perfection. The simple combination of fresh mozzarella, garlic, and Pecorino Romano creates a harmonious balance. Fresh basil and good olive oil bring everything together. A classic that lets the quality of the ingredients shine. Amazing according to reviewers.
Hellboy
PizzaThe most popular pie at Paulie Gee's and a must-order every time. The hot honey drizzle adds a spicy-sweet punch that balances the rich cheese and cured meat. Baked in the wood-fired oven until the crust is crispy and charred. Reviewers consistently single out the Hellboy as one of the best pizzas they've ever had.
King Harry
PizzaThe prosciutto di Parma is laid across the top right after the pizza comes out of the oven, so that it practically melts into the mozzarella. The salty, delicate prosciutto contrasts beautifully with the rich cheese. A refined take on classic ingredients.
Vegan Shmoogula
PizzaPaulie Gee's full vegan pizza menu means non-dairy diners can enjoy the same thin crust, wood-fired experience. This pizza features fresh arugula and Aleppo chili oil for depth. Vegan mozzarella has improved significantly, and this pizza showcases modern vegan cooking.
Grapeful Dead
PizzaOne of Paulie Gee's creative and funny-named specialty pizzas. The pickled grapes add an unexpected sweet and tangy note that works beautifully with the cheese and crust. A great example of Paulie Gee's willingness to take risks and experiment.
About Paulie Gee's
Paulie Gee's opened in 2010 and helped birth the hot honey trend that swept the city. The brick oven pizzeria features thin crust pies with creative and funny names, a full vegan menu, and an almost retro neighborhood feel despite its legendary status. Thin crust is perfectly baked in the hot brick oven, consistently ranked among NYC's best pizza and competitive with pizza in Italy. The restaurant is now easy to get a table, making it an ideal neighborhood spot for pizza parties or casual dinners.
Top 5 dishes at Paulie Gee's:
- The Mootz – 92% recommended(Signature)
- Hellboy – 95% recommended(Signature)
- King Harry – 90% recommended(Signature)
- Vegan Shmoogula – 85% recommended
- Grapeful Dead – 82% recommended
Details
- Cuisine:
- Pizza
- Price Range:
- $$
- Phone:
- +1 (347) 987-3747
- Website:
- Visit Website
- Services:
- Dine-in, Vegan Options
- Reservations:
- Book a Table
Hours
- Friday:
- 12:00 PM - 2:00 AM(Open Now)
- Sunday:
- 12:00 PM - 11:00 PM
- Monday:
- 5:00 PM - 11:00 PM
- Tuesday:
- 5:00 PM - 11:00 PM
- Wednesday:
- 5:00 PM - 11:00 PM
- Thursday:
- 5:00 PM - 2:00 AM
- Saturday:
- 12:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Wood-fired pizzas are dine-in only. No slices, no takeout pies. Sit down and enjoy your pizza hot out of the oven. The experience is part of the draw.
Mike's Hot Honey is available as an add-on to any pizza. Paulie Gee's helped birth the hot honey pizza trend in NYC. Try the Hellboy with hot honey first.
No splitting of checks—only one payment per party. Come hungry and order multiple pies to share. The restaurant is easy to get a table during off-peak times.
Full vegan menu available. Paulie Gee's takes vegan pizza seriously with quality vegan mozzarella and creative toppings. Non-dairy diners get the same wood-fired experience.
Two blocks away is Paulie Gee's Slice Shop with some of the best cheese pizza slices in the city. Perfect for quick lunch or grabbing a slice on the go.
Page last updated: