Where is the best pizza margherita in New York?

Based on diner recommendations, the best pizza margherita in New York is at L'Industrie Pizza (99% recommended). We compared 12 restaurants serving pizza margherita.

How much does pizza margherita cost in New York?

Pizza Margherita prices in New York range from $4.50 to $30.80 across 12 restaurants.

All Dish Comparisons in New York

Best Pizza Margherita in New York

12 restaurants compared

Price range: $4.50 – $30.80

Avg recommendation: 94%

Top 5 Pizza Margherita in New York (Quick Answer)

Based on diner recommendations across 12 restaurants:

L'Industrie Pizza — 99% recommended, $7.50 (Williamsburg)
Lucali — 99% recommended, $30.00 (Carroll Gardens)
Denino's Pizzeria — 99% recommended, $30.80 (Greenwich Village)
50 Kalò — 96% recommended, $14.00 (SoHo)
Mario's — 96% recommended, $20.00 (Arthur Avenue)

Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.

All 12 Restaurants Compared

#199% recommend

L'Industrie Pizza

Williamsburg·$

Burrata Slice

$7.50

Margherita slice topped with a whole glob of fresh burrata and basil oil.

Tip: Spread the burrata ball across the whole slice with your napkin or a plastic knife before you eat. It ensures a perfect ratio in every bite.

#299% recommend

Lucali

Carroll Gardens·$$$

Margherita Pizza

$30.00

A thin-crust, wood-fired pie with a secret three-cheese blend and fresh basil.

Tip: Add garlic and hot peppers—they're free and they're kept in little jars on the table. The fresh garlic takes the pie to another level.

#399% recommend

Denino's Pizzeria

Greenwich Village·$$

Cheese Pie

$30.80

Large 16-inch thin-crust pie with aged mozzarella and a savory tomato sauce.

Tip: This is one of the few pizzas in NYC that doesn't 'flop.' The crust is remarkably crisp. It's the best way to taste the quality of their traditional 1930s recipe.

#496% recommend