The dish that started it all. The crust is thick, flaky, and remarkably buttery, filled with a dense, tart mixture of sour cherries that isn't overly sweetened. It's a textbook execution of the American classic, relying on the natural brightness of the fruit. It is often cited as the best fruit pie in New York City. Reviewers mention it's mandatory to order a slice, even if you're full.
Tips from diners
Ask for it warm with a scoop of their house-made vanilla ice cream (a la mode). The temperature contrast makes the buttery crust even better.
The restaurant's most celebrated breakfast item. These pancakes are made using a classic recipe from the 'Father of American Gastronomy,' resulting in a texture that is remarkably light and airy with a rich, buttery flavor. They are served with real maple syrup and fresh fruit. Reviewers consistently call them the best pancakes in Manhattan, a brilliant example of traditional American baking at its peak.
Tips from diners
Get the 'Pancake Flight' if you can't decide—it lets you try the James Beard version alongside the 1890 Sourdough pancakes. The sourdough ones have a great tang that balances the syrup.
A high-quality comfort burger that avoids unnecessary trends. The patty is a custom blend of prime cuts, griddled until it has a deep char but remains perfectly medium-rare. It's served with sharp white cheddar and house-made pickles. It's a favorite for those wanting a substantial but refined comfort meal in a classic Tribeca setting.
A robust and satisfying brunch favorite. A large, juicy chicken breast is breaded in a seasoned buttermilk coating and fried until golden and crispy, then served on top of the signature light pancakes. It's a favorite for its balance of savory meat and sweet, airy dough. Reviewers highlight the lack of greasiness in the chicken as a standout feature.
Originally opened as a pie baking company on Thanksgiving Day, Bubby's has grown into a quintessential New York comfort food destination. Located in a large, bright space in Tribeca, it serves American classics made from scratch using high-quality sourcing. It is celebrated for its commitment to family-style hospitality and its status as the city's premier destination for traditional breakfast and brunch staples.
Reservations are mandatory for weekend brunch. They book up several days in advance. If you're a walk-in, the bar is often held for solo diners and pairs.
Bubby's is remarkably child-friendly. They have a great kids' menu and the room is large enough that you won't feel out of place with a stroller. It's a favorite for multi-generational family brunches.
The line outside can look long, but they move tables very efficiently. Put your name in and head to the nearby Hudson River Park for a walk while you wait.
Page last updated: