The classic New Haven style pizza that defines Piece — a chewy yet crispy thin crust brushed with olive oil and topped with red sauce and aged Pecorino Romano. This is the baseline for how Piece builds its custom pizzas.
Tips from diners
The New Haven style pizza is small and designed for 1-2 people — the thin crust and balance of toppings is the baseline to understand Piece's cooking style.
Get there early on weekend nights or expect a wait — the bar area seats first-come.
The O.M.G. showcases Piece's approach to reinventing New Haven pizza — innovative toppings and flavor combinations that respect the traditional thin crust while being decidedly modern. This pizza appears frequently in mentions of Piece's most memorable dishes.
Tips from diners
Order from the counter for faster service and a view of the kitchen — the counter seats get priority during busy hours.
Piece's on-site brewery produces award-winning beers that pair perfectly with the pizzas. The rotating selection includes seasonal styles and house favorites. A flight is the best way to explore what the brewery is currently offering.
Tips from diners
Ask the bartender for pairing recommendations — they know which house brews work best with each pizza style.
A collaboration between two Chicago institutions — Piece uses the famous Atomic Sausage from Hot Doug's to top their thin crust. The sausage brings heat and spice to the crispy pizza.
Tips from diners
If you love spicy food, ask for extra Atomic Sausage — it transforms the pizza.
Mama Gulia's World Famous Meatballs are a restaurant-famous topping that brings Italian tradition to the New Haven crust. The meatballs are house-made and paired with red sauce and cheese.
Tips from diners
Make a reservation for weekend dinners — seating moves faster than a walk-in wait.
Piece Brewery opened in July 2001 when founder Bill Jacobs brought New Haven's iconic pizza style to Wicker Park. Rick Nielsen, the lead guitarist for Cheap Trick, is one of the founding partners. The restaurant has built a reputation for expertly executed thin-crust New Haven pizzas paired with on-site microbrewed beer, and it's now ranked among the most popular indie pizzerias in the nation.
Live band karaoke happens every Saturday at 11 PM — arrive early if you want to avoid the late-night crowd or stay if you want to join the fun.
Piece screens 14 large TVs for sports events — book ahead if you want to watch a big game, or expect a full house.
Private parties and catering are available — call ahead to discuss group dining options and custom menu arrangements.
Similar picks in Chicago
Page last updated: