Arguably the most photographed salad in New York. A towering, architectural stack of perfectly fresh bibb lettuce leaves, dressed in a sharp, bright vinaigrette of mustard, shallots, and sherry vinegar. It is a brilliant example of how a simple dish can be refined into something iconic through ingredient quality and precise dressing.
Tips from diners
It sounds expensive for lettuce, but the dressing is magic. It's the required starter for every table.
Via Carota's take on a burger, but distinctly Italian. It is a thick patty of high-quality beef, hand-chopped and pan-seared until a deep crust forms. It is served bunless, topped only with crispy fried garlic and rosemary. The meat is remarkably juicy and flavorful, intended to be eaten with a fork and knife alongside their famous vegetables.
Tips from diners
Order it medium-rare. The garlic chips on top are essential for the flavor profile.
While I Sodi is the lasagna specialist, Via Carota's Cacio e Pepe is the neighborhood favorite for a quick pasta fix. Using thicker, square-cut tonnarelli, the cheese and pepper cling to the pasta creating a remarkably creamy, emulsified sauce. It is punchy, peppery, and consistently excellent.
Via Carota is the rare restaurant that both locals and tourists adore equally. Inspired by a 17th-century villa in the hills near Florence, the space features reclaimed wood floors, stone walls, and a large communal table. It does not take reservations, which has created a legendary walk-in culture. The menu is a 'love letter' to vegetables, though the pastas and meats are equally refined.
They don't take reservations. Put your name in at the host stand and then grab a drink at their sister bar, Bar Pisellino, across the street. On weekends, the wait can be 2-3 hours.
Lunch on a weekday is the 'pro move.' There is rarely a wait, and the light in the dining room is beautiful. It's the best way to experience the menu without the chaos.
Page last updated: