These cookies are legendary — the kitchen bakes them to order so they arrive warm, with crispy edges and a tender, chewy center. Grill 23 uses quality chocolate and butter, resulting in a refined version of a classic dessert that shouldn't work but does.
Tips from diners
Request ahead if you're celebrating — the kitchen can time this with your main course.
Rich and shareable — order one or two per couple and share.
Grill 23 sources the finest prime beef and ages it for 100 days — significantly longer than most restaurants' 30-40 days. This extended aging concentrates beef flavor and creates incredible tenderness. The 100-day ribeye has a deeper, more concentrated beefy flavor than younger cuts, with a tender, almost buttery texture.
Tips from diners
This is the headline dish — if you want to experience what makes Grill 23 special, order this.
Request your preferred doneness when ordering — the kitchen nails consistency across the whole menu.
A refined take on a classic dessert — moist cake layers, proper coconut cream frosting, and a garnish of toasted coconut. Not overly sweet, with genuine coconut flavor rather than artificial extract.
Tips from diners
A lighter alternative to the chocolate cookies — pairs well with after-dinner cocktails.
The cap is a deeply marbled cut that takes well to high heat. American Kobe beef — while not as heavily marbled as Japanese wagyu — offers a middle ground between traditional dry-aged beef and wagyu, with more intramuscular fat than prime beef but better beef flavor than fully imported wagyu.
Tips from diners
A slightly less expensive option than wagyu that still delivers marbling and tenderness.
Japanese wagyu represents the opposite approach to dry-aged beef — instead of concentrating natural beef flavor, wagyu develops intramuscular fat marbling that renders during cooking. The result is a buttery, melting texture with deep umami richness different from traditional American steaks.
Tips from diners
A luxury option that delivers a different experience from domestic steaks — worth trying to compare.
Grill 23 & Bar opened in 1983 in the historic Salada Tea Building and has maintained its position as Boston's premier steakhouse for over 40 years. In 2017, it became the first Boston restaurant to receive Wine Spectator's prestigious Grand Award, an honor it has maintained annually since. The restaurant features a 2000+ bottle wine list, prime dry-aged beef, and fresh seafood in a refined setting of mahogany paneling and Corinthian columns.
Reserve well in advance — Grill 23 maintains consistent demand due to its reputation. Weekend reservations should be booked several weeks ahead.
The 2000+ bottle wine list is the centerpiece of the experience. Ask your server for recommendations rather than navigating solo — the wine program is genuinely world-class.
The dining room preserves the original architecture of the 1927 Salada Tea Building — the mahogany paneling and massive Corinthian columns create a classic steakhouse atmosphere that's becoming rare.
Page last updated: