A favorite for those wanting a more robust and savory breakfast option. Their house-made whitefish salad is packed with large chunks of smoky fish and seasoned with just enough mayo to provide a creamy, crunchy texture. It is a favorite for its lack of 'filler' and its consistent, deep smoky flavor. Reviewers often cite it as the best whitefish salad in the neighborhood.
Tips from diners
Add a slice of fresh tomato—it provides a bright acidic lift to the rich, smoky fish. The plain bagel is the best choice here to let the salad's flavor be the star.
The quintessential H&H order. High-quality Atlantic salmon is salt-cured and cold-smoked to a buttery consistency, hand-sliced precisely, and piled onto a fresh, hand-rolled bagel. It's balanced with a thick layer of plain cream cheese and the 'trimmings' (tomato, onion, capers). It is remarkably consistent and sets the city-wide bar for high-volume bagel quality. Reviewers consistently name it as the best way to experience the H&H tradition.
Tips from diners
Get it on an everything bagel for the full flavor profile. The seeds and aromatics perfectly balance the rich, fatty salmon. Most regulars eat them exactly as they come, without toasting.
A favorite for those who enjoy earthy, complex flavors. The pumpernickel bagel is particularly dense and dark, providing a savory base for the rich, herb-forward scallion cream cheese. It represents the heart of the New York 'savory breakfast' tradition, showcasing the quality of the bakery's traditional dough recipes.
Originally founded on the Upper West Side, H&H Bagels is a foundational pillar of New York City's appetizing tradition. Celebrated for its commitment to the traditional method—hand-rolling, kettle-boiling, and baking on burlap-covered boards—it produces a bagel with a uniquely thick, chewy crust and a dense, flavor-dense center. It remains one of the most respected bagel operations in the city, providing the benchmark for the New York style.
The line moves incredibly fast because it is a high-volume operation. If you see a crowd, don't worry—the counter staff are pros and you'll usually have your bagel in under 10 minutes.
H&H is famous for its 'no-toasting' policy for its freshest bagels to preserve the soft, hand-rolled texture. While they might do it now at some locations, the 'pro move' is to eat them fresh right out of the basket.
There is virtually no seating inside. Most people take their bagels to go—the East River promenade is just a few blocks away and is a perfect spot for a scenic breakfast.
Page last updated: