Best Steak in New York
7 restaurants compared
Top 5 Steak in New York (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 7 restaurants:
- Casa Mono — 97% recommended, $36.00 (Gramercy)
- St. Anselm — 95% recommended, $29.00 (Williamsburg)
- Peter Luger Steak House — 94% recommended, $147.90 (Williamsburg)
- Txula Steak — 92% recommended, $95.00 (Hudson Yards)
- St. Anselm — 90% recommended, $48.00 (Williamsburg)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 7 Restaurants Compared
Casa Mono
Skirt Steak with Romesco
$36.00
Charcoal-grilled skirt steak served with traditional almond and pepper sauce.
St. Anselm
Hanger Steak (Butcher's Steak)
$29.00
Signature grilled beef hanger steak with a beautifully charred exterior and tender interior.
Peter Luger Steak House
Porterhouse Steak for Two
$147.90
Hand-selected, dry-aged prime beef cooked under a high-temperature broiler and served with Luger sauce.
Txula Steak
Txuletón (60-Day Aged Ribeye)
$95.00
Premium Ibérico or American Wagyu ribeye aged 60 days and charcoal-grilled.
St. Anselm
Rib Eye (Ax Handle)
$48.00
Large grilled rib eye steak cooked over open flame, juicy and well-marbled.
Angelo's of Mulberry Street
Filet Mignon
$48.00
Prime cut beef steak cooked to perfection, served with seasonal vegetables and potatoes.
Minetta Tavern
Beef Filet with Sauce au Poivre
$48.00
Grilled filet mignon dressed with a classic peppercorn sauce.