The foundation of the menu. It uses the highest quality sun-ripened tomatoes and creamy buffalo mozzarella on a light, airy crust with a perfect char. Reviewers call it a reliable and very satisfying version of this Italian classic.
Tips from diners
The crust is the highlight here — nice and pillowy. Use the 'crust dippers' to finish every bit of the dough.
The quintessential Pizza Pilgrims order. It features high-quality pepperoni alongside spicy 'nduja-style rounds, topped with a generous drizzle of house-made spicy honey. Reviewers consistently praise the incredible balance of heat, salt, and sweetness.
Tips from diners
The spicy honey is non-negotiable. It really makes the dish and sets it apart from standard pepperoni pizzas.
A favorite sweet treat that demonstrates the kitchen's playful approach. It combines the creamy coffee notes of a tiramisu with generous layers of Nutella. Reviewers consistently praise the indulgent flavor profile.
Tips from diners
It's a proper showstopper. Very rich — perfect for sharing with a friend after your pizza feast.
A favored starter that has quickly become a signature side item. The balls feature a properly cheesy pasta center, encased in a light, crispy panko batter. Reviewers highlight the textural contrast and the savory kick.
Tips from diners
These are incredibly addictive. Great for sharing with a group alongside a round of cold Italian beers.
A favorite for cheese lovers. This white base pizza features a complex blend including ricotta, gorgonzola, and burrata, finished with a unique smoked chilli jam for a savory-sweet kick. Multiple reviewers describe it as a rich and very successful flavor profile.
Tips from diners
It's extremely rich. One is easily enough for two people to share along with a lighter salad.
Started by brothers Thom and James Elliot in a van, Pizza Pilgrims has become a pillar of London's pizza revolution. Celebrated for its 72-hour proofed dough and high-quality ingredients sourced directly from Italy, the Dean Street flagship offers a high-energy, authentic Neapolitan experience in a relaxed, 'pizzeria' setting.
The restaurant has a very high-energy, buzzy atmosphere. It's a great spot for a fun group dinner before a show.
Try their house-made lemonade — it's very refreshing and a great non-alcoholic pairing for the rich pizzas.
The service is typically very efficient, making it a great option for a quick but proper meal when you're in a hurry in the West End.
Page last updated: