A technical dish that separates good risotto from proper risotto. The rice is toasted, then stirred constantly with stock, saffron, and bone marrow until it reaches the ideal creamy-but-structured consistency. The saffron brings color and subtle flavor. This is the kitchen showing restraint and precision — the ingredients are minimal but each must be treated with care.
Tips from diners
Order this as a side or standalone course — it's rich enough to anchor a meal, light enough to precede the steak.
The centerpiece of Toscano's menu: a 22 oz. sirloin that owner Paoli ages himself before the kitchen grills it over charcoal. The high heat creates a crust while the center remains tender and pink. The aged beef carries depth that fresh beef cannot. Served with patate al forno (roasted potatoes) and spinaci aglio e olio — simple, classical Italian preparations that let the steak shine.
Tips from diners
Request this cooked medium-rare — the kitchen understands the Tuscan preference and won't over-cook.
This is the highlight of the menu — order it without hesitation if you enjoy steak.
A whole Cornish hen (smaller than chicken, more tender) is flattened and grilled until the skin is crackling-crisp and meat stays juicy. The cooking method, called mattone or brick-press, is a classic Tuscan technique that Toscano executes well. Root vegetables around it become caramelized from the grill heat. This is poultry cooked with respect.
Tips from diners
This feeds one person generously and is lighter than the steak if you want something hearty but not excessive.
Osso buco: fall-apart veal shank braised low and slow until the collagen breaks down into gelatin that coats the meat and sauce. The marrow inside the bone is the prize. Served with saffron risotto and the natural pan reduction — no heavy cream, just reduced braise liquid. This is comfort food made with care, a dish that demonstrates how technique and patience elevate simple ingredients.
Tips from diners
This is a celebratory dish — the presentation with risotto is generous and sharable.
A traditional Tuscan fisherman's stew built from white fish, clams, mussels, and sometimes shrimp in a spicy tomato broth with fish stock base. The flavors deepen as it sits — nothing is rushed. The seafood is added at different times to hit ideal doneness. Grilled bread rubbed with garlic is essential for soaking up the spiced broth.
Tips from diners
Ask for grilled bread on the side — it's meant for soaking the spiced broth, and it's essential to the experience.
Toscano opened in 1983 on Charles Street thanks to Florence native Vinicio Paoli and co-owners Azita Bina-Seibel and John Hauck. Paoli brought his Tuscan hometown's regional dishes and philosophy to Boston. After David D'Alessandro purchased the restaurant in 2006, it modernized while maintaining its core identity. The charcoal grill is the heart of the operation — Paoli ages sirloin himself before it hits the open flame. Hand-made risotto, properly prepared seasonal dishes, and 40 years of neighborhood devotion define the restaurant.
Reservations essential, especially weekends. Charles Street is the heart of Beacon Hill — this is a rite of passage dinner.
The intimate space and European aesthetic make this romantic without being overwrought. Proper tableside service, knowledge sommelier.
Monday-Thursday are quieter than weekends. You'll get more attention from the kitchen and better table availability.
Toscano has anchored Charles Street since 1983 — the neighborhood considers it a local institution. Paoli's Tuscan roots define the food.
Page last updated: