A nod to the restaurant's origins as a hot dog cart. A high-quality beef frank is split and grilled, then topped with traditional Chicago-style ingredients: neon-green relish, onions, cucumber, pickles, tomatoes, sport peppers, and celery salt. It is a favorite for those wanting a flavor-dense, non-burger option. Reviewers often mention it's the best version of the Chicago classic outside of Illinois.
Tips from diners
The sport peppers provide a sharp, vinegary heat that is essential. It's a very substantial dog, so it works as a great light lunch on its own.
The quintessential modern American burger. A custom blend of high-quality beef is smashed onto a hot griddle to create a savory, salty crust, while the center remains juicy. It's topped with simple American cheese and the signature 'ShackSauce,' then served on a pillowy soft potato bun. It is a brilliant example of consistency and balance, consistently rated as one of the best value burgers in the city. Reviewers praise the way the bun integrates with the meat.
Tips from diners
Get the double burger. The ratio of the crispy 'smashed' edges to the soft bun is even better. The ShackSauce is what binds everything together—it's remarkably consistent.
A textbook execution of the American fast-food classic. The crinkle-cut provides a higher surface area for maximum crunch while the interior remains soft and fluffy. They are served hot and heavily salted. While some modern spots prefer hand-cut fries, Shake Shack's version is celebrated for its nostalgic texture and its status as the perfect accompaniment to the smashed burger.
A refined end to the meal. The 'Black & White' is a favorite, blending the rich, house-made chocolate and vanilla custards into a thick and creamy shake. It is hand-spun to order and has a much more concentrated flavor and denser texture than standard soft-serve shakes. Reviewers consistently highlight the quality of the dairy.
Originally opened as a hot dog cart in 2001 to support the Madison Square Park Conservancy, Shake Shack evolved into a permanent kiosk in 2004. Founded by Danny Meyer, it redefined the 'fast-casual' category by applying fine-dining standards to simple burgers, fries, and shakes. While there are now hundreds of locations worldwide, the original park setting remains the heart of the brand, celebrated for its high-quality ingredients and its status as a New York cultural anchor.
The original park location is entirely outdoors. On nice weekend afternoons, the wait can be 45-60 minutes. Use the 'Shack Cam' on their website to check the line before you head over.
There are plenty of green park tables nearby, but they are first-come, first-served. If you're a group, have one person stake out a table while the others stand in line.
They have a very efficient digital pager system. Once you order, you can wander a bit within the park—it's a much more pleasant way to wait than standing in a cramped room.
Page last updated: