All Ingredients in New York
Best Scallop Dishes in New York
4 restaurants compared
Price range: $8.50 – $70.00
Avg recommendation: 88%
Top 4 Scallop Dishes in New York (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 4 restaurants:
- Barely Touched Scallop with Royal Osetra Caviar at Le Bernardin — 92% recommended, $65.00 (Midtown West)
- Stonington Sea Scallop with Ricotta Dumplings and Black Truffle at Per Se — 87% recommended, $70.00 (Hell's Kitchen / Columbus Circle)
- Broiled Peconic Bay Sea Scallops at Grand Central Oyster Bar — 86% recommended, $34.00 (Midtown East)
- Pan-Fried Noodles with Seafood at H K Wonton Garden — 85% recommended, $8.50 (Chinatown)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 4 Scallop Dishes
#192% recommend
Barely Touched Scallop with Royal Osetra Caviar
Le BernardinMidtown West·$$$$
$65.00
Raw diver scallop topped with premium Russian caviar and finished oil.
Tip: This opens the meal perfectly — order it if you get the chef's tasting. The room-temperature preparation is what makes it different from other raw scallop dishes.
#287% recommend
Stonington Sea Scallop with Ricotta Dumplings and Black Truffle
Per SeHell's Kitchen / Columbus Circle·$$$$
$70.00
Pan-seared Maine sea scallop with housemade ricotta dumplings and black winter truffle beurre blanc.
Tip: This represents the restaurant's philosophy perfectly — pristine protein, minimal garnish, perfect execution. Ask for it if you want to taste the ingredients rather than the technique.
#386% recommend
Broiled Peconic Bay Sea Scallops
Grand Central Oyster BarMidtown East·$$$
$34.00
Large scallops with casino butter, a blend of spices and herbs.
#485% recommend
Pan-Fried Noodles with Seafood
H K Wonton GardenChinatown·$$
$8.50
Crispy fried noodles topped with shrimp, squid, scallops, and a savory gravy.