All Dish Comparisons in New York
Best Toast in New York
3 restaurants compared
Price range: $5.50 – $19.00
Avg recommendation: 93%
Top 3 Toast in New York (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 3 restaurants:
- Misi — 98% recommended, $19.00 (Williamsburg)
- Murray's Bagels — 92% recommended, $8.50 (Chelsea)
- Pull-Tab Coffee — 90% recommended, $5.50 (Midtown)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 3 Restaurants Compared
#198% recommend
Misi
Williamsburg·$$$
Ricotta Toast with Marinated Peppers
$19.00
Thick sourdough toast topped with fresh ricotta and sweet-and-sour peppers.
Tip: Order one for every two people. The peppers change seasonally, but they are always remarkably flavor-dense. It's the perfect way to judge the kitchen's respect for ingredients.
#292% recommend
Murray's Bagels
Chelsea·$$
French Toast Bagel with Walnut Schmear
$8.50
Sweet French toast bagel topped with crunchy roasted walnut cream cheese.
#390% recommend
Pull-Tab Coffee
Midtown·$
Butter Toast with Kaya
$5.50
Buttery toast layered with Kaya, the Singaporean coconut jam.
Tip: Order the Aerofoam + Butter Toast combo for $12.50—it's the perfect pairing and a great value.