All Dish Comparisons in New York
Best Stew in New York
3 restaurants compared
Price range: $12.00 – $28.00
Avg recommendation: 92%
Top 3 Stew in New York (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 3 restaurants:
- Old Sport Food — 97% recommended, $19.49 (Forest Hills)
- Grand Central Oyster Bar — 95% recommended, $28.00 (Midtown East)
- Malecon — 85% recommended, $12.00 (Washington Heights)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 3 Restaurants Compared
#197% recommend
Old Sport Food
Forest Hills·$$
Big Plate Chicken (Da Pan Ji)
$19.49
Hearty bone-in chicken stew with potatoes, chilies, and hand-pulled wide noodles.
Tip: The potatoes are the best part—they soak up all the chili oil and spice. It's a huge portion, so order it for the table to share. Ask for Level 3 spice if you like a real kick.
#295% recommend
Grand Central Oyster Bar
Midtown East·$$$
Pan Roast
$28.00
Creamy, buttery stew with fish or shellfish served in a cast iron pan.
#385% recommend
Malecon
Washington Heights·$$
Sancocho
$12.00
Hearty stew loaded with oxtail, smoked pork chop, and guinea hen.