All Dish Comparisons in New York
Best Steak Frites in New York
5 restaurants compared
Price range: $38.00 – $49.00
Avg recommendation: 94%
Top 5 Steak Frites in New York (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 5 restaurants:
- The Odeon — 98% recommended, $49.00 (Tribeca)
- Pastis — 98% recommended, $39.00 (Meatpacking District)
- Balthazar — 92% recommended, $42.00 (SoHo)
- Le Parisien — 92% recommended, $38.00 (Murray Hill)
- Cafe Luxembourg — 89% recommended, $42.00 (Upper West Side)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 5 Restaurants Compared
#198% recommend
The Odeon
Tribeca·$$$$
$49.00
8 oz. aged prime NY strip steak served with maître d'hôtel butter and French fries.
Tip: The fries are legendary. Ask for a side of the house-made béarnaise—it's remarkably rich and elevates both the steak and the fries to another level.
#298% recommend
Pastis
Meatpacking District·$$$$
$39.00
Classic pan-seared steak served with house-made maître d'hôtel butter or bearnaise and thin fries.
Tip: Get it with the bearnaise sauce. It's made fresh several times a day and has a perfect tarragon brightness that cuts through the rich steak. The portion of fries is large enough to share.
#392% recommend
Balthazar
SoHo·$$$
$42.00
NY Strip steak cooked au poivre with crispy pommes frites and sautéed spinach.
Tip: Order the steak frites. 200 are sold daily because it's the best version in the city. The peppercorn crust is essential — don't ask for it without the pepper.
#492% recommend
Le Parisien
Murray Hill·$$$
Bistrot Steak Frites
$38.00
Hand-cut steak with red wine thyme sauce and glazed shallots, served with crispy fries.
#589% recommend
Cafe Luxembourg
Upper West Side·$$$
$42.00
Grilled steak with bearnaise sauce and crispy French fries.