Best Quesadilla in New York
6 restaurants compared
Top 5 Quesadilla in New York (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 6 restaurants:
- Tlayuda Oaxaqueña Sr San Pablo, $6.50 (Jackson Heights)
- Tlayuda Oaxaqueña Sr San Pablo, $6.50 (Jackson Heights)
- Quesadillas Doña Maty — 94% recommended, $7.50 (East Harlem)
- Quesadillas Doña Maty — 91% recommended, $7.75 (East Harlem)
- Quesadillas Doña Maty — 88% recommended, $8.50 (East Harlem)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 6 Restaurants Compared
Tlayuda Oaxaqueña Sr San Pablo
Chorizo Quesadilla
$6.50
Hand-pressed quesadilla with salty chorizo and melted cheese.
Tlayuda Oaxaqueña Sr San Pablo
Quesadillas
$6.50
Hand-pressed masa with stretchy cheese and chorizo, cooked on a griddle.
Quesadillas Doña Maty
Pollo Asado Quesadilla
$7.50
Handmade corn tortilla filled with grilled chicken, bell peppers, onions, garlic, and melted queso Oaxaca.
Quesadillas Doña Maty
Carnitas Quesadilla
$7.75
Crispy shredded pork with queso Oaxaca, onions, and cilantro in a charred handmade tortilla.
Quesadillas Doña Maty
Quesadilla de Huitaloche
$8.50
Handmade tortilla with corn fungus (huitaloche), queso Oaxaca, epazote, and poblano peppers.
Quesadillas Doña Maty
Al Pastor Quesadilla
$8.00
Spiced marinated pork with pineapple, onions, and cilantro in a handmade corn tortilla.