Best Gelato in New York
3 restaurants compared
Price range: $8.50 – $9.00
Avg recommendation: 92%
Top 3 Gelato in New York (Quick Answer)
Our editors' picks across 3 restaurants:
- Superiority Burger — score 96/100, $9.00 (East Village)
- Her Name is Han — score 94/100, $8.50 (Koreatown)
- Lilia — score 85/100, $9.00 (Williamsburg)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 3 Restaurants Compared
#1Score 96/100
Superiority Burger
East Village·$$
Daily Gelato
$9.00
Rotating seasonal gelato made with high-quality ingredients.
#2Score 94/100
Her Name is Han
Koreatown·$$
Black Sesame Gelato
$8.50
Intensely nutty and savory-sweet black sesame flavored ice cream.
#3Score 85/100
Lilia
Williamsburg·$$$
Soft Serve Gelato with Toppings
$9.00
House-made soft-serve gelato served with a choice of toppings like candied orange rind or honeycomb.
Tip: Order the soft serve — it's lighter and more refreshing than the heavier chocolate torta. Pair it with candied orange if you want brightness.