All Dish Comparisons in New York
Best Fish in New York
3 restaurants compared
Price range: $30.00 – $52.00
Avg recommendation: 89%
Top 3 Fish in New York (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 3 restaurants:
- Sylvia's — 94% recommended, $30.00 (Harlem)
- Atomix — 90% recommended, (NoMad)
- Maison Passerelle — 82% recommended, $52.00 (Financial District)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 3 Restaurants Compared
#194% recommend
Sylvia's
Harlem·$$$
Southern Fried Catfish
$30.00
Fresh catfish fillets cornmeal-crusted and fried until golden.
#290% recommend
Atomix
NoMad·$$$$
Halibut with Sea Urchin and Rice Porridge
Delicate halibut fillet served with sea urchin and creamy rice porridge.
Tip: This is one of the most technically clean courses on the menu—the halibut is cooked to absolute perfection with just enough seasoning to let the fish speak.
#382% recommend
Maison Passerelle
Financial District·$$$
Pan-Seared Fish with Provençal Vegetables
$52.00
Fresh seasonal fish with tomato, zucchini, eggplant, and olive oil.
Tip: Great alternative to heavier preparations — the vegetables are cooked perfectly and the fish is delicate.