Bi-Rite's salted caramel is pure balance — the caramel is cooked until dark and almost bitter, then salt is added to cut through the sweetness and amplify the burnt sugar notes. The ice cream base is rich enough to coat your mouth without being heavy. This is the most popular flavor and appears on the rotation nearly every day.
Tips from diners
This is always available. It's the benchmark flavor — taste it first, then experiment with the seasonal options.
Bi-Rite's salted caramel has less sugar than most competitors. It doesn't taste as sweet but reveals more caramel complexity once you slow down and savor it.
While other shops use packaged cookies, Bi-Rite makes their own chocolate cookies for this flavor — crispy, dark, and slightly bitter. The cookies are broken by hand and mixed into a rich but not-too-sweet vanilla base. It's comfort food ice cream, but with better ingredients than the name might suggest.
Tips from diners
This is available year-round and never disappoints. A safe choice if you're overwhelmed by the seasonal options.
This is a signature seasonal flavor (spring into early summer when strawberries are best). Fresh strawberries are folded into the ice cream base, and then aged balsamic vinegar is drizzled through, creating tart, complex flavor notes that elevate simple strawberry into something more interesting. The sourness from the vinegar makes the strawberry taste more like itself.
Tips from diners
This flavor only appears in spring and early summer when strawberries are in season. If you see it, order it — it's what defines the season at Bi-Rite.
Made with espresso from Ritual Coffee Roasters (a nearby Mission institution), this ice cream is smooth and not overly bitter. The real star is the handmade almond toffee mixed in — the almonds are toasted each day, tossed with warm caramel, then cooled and broken into shards. Each bite catches a piece of crunchy, salty-sweet toffee.
Tips from diners
This is the best coffee ice cream in San Francisco because of the toffee element. Coffee ice cream alone can taste bitter, but the toffee balances it perfectly.
This seasonal flavor (usually spring/early summer) combines steeped organic dried lavender with hyper-local honey from Bay Area Bee Company. The lavender is aromatic without being soapy, and the honey adds a subtle floral sweetness. It's unusual enough that some people love it immediately, while others prefer trying it as a small taste before committing to a scoop.
Tips from diners
Ask for a taste before ordering — lavender is divisive. If you like floral flavors, this will become your favorite.
Bi-Rite Creamery was founded in 2006 by Kris Hoogerhyde and Anne Walker, passionate bakers who wanted to make ice cream the right way. They partnered with Straus Family Creamery (45 miles north of San Francisco) to use local, organic dairy — making Bi-Rite the first ice cream shop in the region to do so. Every flavor is made from scratch with handmade inclusions: almond toffee is made daily for their Ritual Coffee Toffee, chocolate chunks are cut fresh, and seasonal fruit comes from the farmers market. The Mission District location on 18th Street opens directly onto the sidewalk across from Mission Dolores Park.
Buy here and walk 2 blocks north to Mission Dolores Park with your cone. This is the iconic SF summer ritual. Eat quickly or the ice cream will melt into your hands.
This location is always busy on warm afternoons and weekends. Come before 2 PM or after 7 PM to avoid lines. The ice cream is the same quality whenever you arrive.
They sell pints of all flavors for home consumption. If you have a favorite, ask if they can pack a full pint rather than portioning by the scoop.
Check their menu board for the seasonal rotation. They introduce new limited flavors monthly based on ingredient availability. Try one seasonal flavor per visit to track the year.
Similar picks in San Francisco
Page last updated: