Best Toast in San Francisco
4 restaurants compared
Price range: $5.50 – $8.00
Avg recommendation: 92%
Top 4 Toast in San Francisco (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 4 restaurants:
- The Mill, $7.50 (NoPa)
- The Mill, $8.00 (NoPa)
- The Mill, $5.50 (NoPa)
- The Mill — 92% recommended, $6.50 (NoPa)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 4 Restaurants Compared
#1
The Mill
NoPa·$
Whole Grain Sourdough Toast with Ricotta and Housemade Jam
$7.50
Toast topped with creamy ricotta cheese and seasonal housemade jam.
Tip: The ricotta toast is slightly sweeter without being cloying — perfect if you want something richer than plain butter.
#2
The Mill
NoPa·$
Whole Grain Sourdough Toast with Smashed Avocado
$8.00
House-milled sourdough toast topped with creamy smashed avocado and seasonings.
Tip: Ask the staff if the avocados look good today before ordering — they'll be honest about whether they're ripe.
#3
The Mill
NoPa·$
Cinnamon Sugar Toast
$5.50
Sourdough toast topped with cinnamon, sugar, and butter.
Tip: A great no-fuss option when you're in a hurry — order it to-go and eat it while walking.
#492% recommend
The Mill
NoPa·$
Whole Grain Sourdough Toast with Cultured Butter and Jam
$6.50
Thickly sliced toast from house-milled whole grain sourdough, topped with excellent butter and housemade seasonal jam.
Tip: Get here before 8:30am if you want to avoid a 20+ minute line — toast availability runs out regularly.