Best Seafood in New York
4 restaurants compared
Price range: $24.00 – $54.00
Avg recommendation: 97%
Top 4 Seafood in New York (Quick Answer)
Our editors' picks across 4 restaurants:
- Casa Mono — score 99/100, $24.00 (Gramercy)
- Cervo's — score 98/100, $26.00 (Lower East Side)
- Gramercy Tavern (The Tavern) — score 96/100, $54.00 (Flatiron)
- Chambers — score 96/100, $38.00 (Tribeca)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 4 Restaurants Compared
#1Score 99/100
Casa Mono
Gramercy·$$$$
Razor Clams a la Plancha
$24.00
Fresh razor clams grilled with olive oil, garlic, and fresh herbs.
Tip: One order usually comes with 4-5 clams. If you're a table of four, order two plates immediately—they're the best razor clams in the city and will be gone in seconds.
#2Score 98/100
Cervo's
Lower East Side·$$$
Prawns a la Plancha
$26.00
Large head-on prawns grilled with salt and olive oil.
Tip: Eat the heads. That's where all the flavor is. If you're squeamish, this might not be the dish for you, but it's the best part of the Cervo's experience.
#3Score 96/100
Gramercy Tavern (The Tavern)
Flatiron·$$$$
Seafood Platter
$54.00
A curated selection of fresh, seasonal raw and chilled seafood.
Tip: The oysters are remarkably fresh. Ask the bartender for a pairing from their excellent white wine list—they have some rare coastal bottles that are perfect for this platter.
#4Score 96/100
Chambers
Tribeca·$$$
Seared Long Island Fluke
$38.00
Local fluke served with shelling beans and a preserved lemon pan sauce.