All Dish Comparisons in New York
Best Pierogi in New York
6 restaurants compared
Price range: $14.00 – $18.00
Avg recommendation: 96%
Top 5 Pierogi in New York (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 6 restaurants:
- Pierozek — 99% recommended, $14.50 (Greenpoint)
- Veselka — 98% recommended, $18.00 (East Village)
- Pierozek — 96% recommended, $15.50 (Greenpoint)
- Pierozek — 95% recommended, $14.00 (Greenpoint)
- Pierozek — 94% recommended, $15.00 (Greenpoint)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 6 Restaurants Compared
#199% recommend
Pierozek
Greenpoint·$$
Ruskie Pierogi
$14.50
Classic Polish dumplings filled with potato, cheese, and caramelized onions.
Tip: These are the gold standard. Make sure to ask for the bacon bits on top—they provide a perfect salty crunch against the soft filling.
#298% recommend
Veselka
East Village·$$
Short Rib Pierogi
$18.00
Handmade dumplings filled with slow-braised beef short rib.
Tip: Get the 'Mixed' plate if it's your first time—it lets you try the short rib alongside the classic potato and cheese. Always ask for them pan-fried.
#396% recommend
Pierozek
Greenpoint·$$
Paulie Gee Pierogi
$15.50
Savory dumplings filled with spicy pepperoni, mozzarella, and chili oil.
Tip: This is much more substantial than the traditional versions. It's a great bridge for people who might be new to Polish food.
#495% recommend
Pierozek
Greenpoint·$$
Blueberry Pierogi
$14.00
Sweet dumplings filled with whole fresh blueberries, served with sweet cream.
#594% recommend
Pierozek
Greenpoint·$$
Meat Pierogi
$15.00
Handmade dumplings filled with savory braised pork shoulder.
#692% recommend
Pierozek
Greenpoint·$$
Murray's Cheese Pierogi
$16.00
Dumplings filled with a curated blend of cheeses from Murray's Cheese Shop.