Best Pie in New York
2 restaurants compared
Price range: $8.50 – $13.00
Avg recommendation: 91%
Top 2 Pie in New York (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 2 restaurants:
- Milk Bar — 97% recommended, $8.50 (East Village)
- Peter Luger Steak House — 85% recommended, $13.00 (Williamsburg)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 2 Restaurants Compared
#197% recommend
Milk Bar
East Village·$$
Milk Bar Pie (formerly Crack Pie)
$8.50
Toasted oat crust with a rich, buttery, gooey filling.
Tip: Share a slice. It's incredibly rich and sugary. If you're staying in the neighborhood, it actually tastes even better when it's cold right out of the fridge the next day.
#285% recommend
Peter Luger Steak House
Williamsburg·$$$
Pecan Pie with Schlag
$13.00
House-made pecan pie topped with freshly whipped cream (schlag).
Tip: If you have room, order the pecan pie. The schlag takes it from good to memorable. It's a heavy finish but appropriate after the steak.