Where is the best oyster in New York?

Based on diner recommendations, the best oyster in New York is at Gramercy Tavern (The Tavern) (96% recommended). We compared 4 restaurants serving oyster.

How much does oyster cost in New York?

Oyster prices in New York range from $18.00 to $54.00 across 4 restaurants.

All Dish Comparisons in New York

Best Oyster in New York

4 restaurants compared

Price range: $18.00 – $54.00

Avg recommendation: 89%

Top 4 Oyster in New York (Quick Answer)

Based on diner recommendations across 4 restaurants:

Gramercy Tavern (The Tavern) — 96% recommended, $54.00 (Flatiron)
Grand Central Oyster Bar — 92% recommended, $18.00 (Midtown East)
Grand Central Oyster Bar — 85% recommended, $22.00 (Midtown East)
Grand Central Oyster Bar — 82% recommended, $20.00 (Midtown East)

Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.

All 4 Restaurants Compared

#196% recommend

Gramercy Tavern (The Tavern)

Flatiron·$$$$

Seafood Platter

$54.00

A curated selection of fresh, seasonal raw and chilled seafood.

Tip: The oysters are remarkably fresh. Ask the bartender for a pairing from their excellent white wine list—they have some rare coastal bottles that are perfect for this platter.

#292% recommend