Best Lobster Roll in New York
1 restaurants compared
Price range: $38.00 – $38.00
Avg recommendation: 97%
Top 1 Lobster Roll in New York (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 1 restaurants:
- Smithereens — 97% recommended, $38.00 (East Village)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 1 Restaurants Compared
#197% recommend
Smithereens
East Village·$$$
$38.00
Cold-water lobster meat brushed with lobster-shell butter in a warm bun.
Tip: The roll is smaller than what you'd get in Maine, but the quality of the meat and the intensity of the lobster butter make it worth the price.