Best Cupcake in New York
1 restaurants compared
Price range: $4.50 – $4.50
Avg recommendation: 96%
Top 1 Cupcake in New York (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 1 restaurants:
- Magnolia Bakery — 96% recommended, $4.50 (West Village)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 1 Restaurants Compared
#196% recommend
Magnolia Bakery
West Village·$$
Red Velvet Cupcake
$4.50
Traditional red velvet cake with a rich, whipped vanilla bean icing.
Tip: The icing is the key here. It's much lighter than standard American buttercream. If you're a chocolate fan, the 'Carrie Cupcake' (vanilla with pink buttercream) is the historic order.