All Dish Comparisons in New York
Best Cookie in New York
4 restaurants compared
Price range: $4.50 – $6.33
Avg recommendation: 96%
Top 4 Cookie in New York (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 4 restaurants:
- Levain Bakery — 99% recommended, $6.33 (Upper West Side)
- Levain Bakery — 97% recommended, $6.33 (Upper West Side)
- Levain Bakery — 95% recommended, $6.33 (Upper West Side)
- Milk Bar — 94% recommended, $4.50 (East Village)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 4 Restaurants Compared
#199% recommend
Levain Bakery
Upper West Side·$$
Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie
$6.33
A massive, six-ounce cookie with a crispy exterior and a molten, gooey center.
Tip: These are best when they're still warm from the oven. If they're cold, pop them in a microwave for 15 seconds to recreate that legendary gooey center. One cookie is plenty for two people—it's very heavy.
#297% recommend
Levain Bakery
Upper West Side·$$
Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookie
$6.33
Rich dark chocolate dough with sweet, creamy peanut butter chips.
Tip: This is the richest cookie on the menu. It pairs perfectly with a cold glass of milk. If you're a chocolate purist, this is the one to get.
#395% recommend
Levain Bakery
Upper West Side·$$
Two Chip Chocolate Chip Cookie
$6.33
Traditional chocolate chip cookie using a blend of two different high-quality chocolates.
#494% recommend
Milk Bar
East Village·$$
Compost Cookie
$4.50
Large chewy cookie packed with pretzels, potato chips, coffee, and chocolate chips.