Best Banana Pudding in New York

1 restaurants compared

Price range: $7.25 – $7.25

Avg recommendation: 99%

Top 1 Banana Pudding in New York (Quick Answer)

Our editors' picks across 1 restaurants:

Magnolia Bakery — score 99/100, $7.25 (West Village)

Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.

All 1 Restaurants Compared

#1Score 99/100

Magnolia Bakery

West Village·$$

Classic Banana Pudding

$7.25

Layers of creamy vanilla pudding, fresh bananas, and crunchy vanilla wafers.

Tip: The medium size is the 'sweet spot' for one person. It's so light you can eat more than you think. If they have the seasonal flavors (like chocolate or pumpkin), try a small, but the classic is the legend.