All Dish Comparisons in New Orleans
Best Steak in New Orleans
3 restaurants compared
Price range: $52.00 – $55.00
Avg recommendation: 93%
Top 3 Steak in New Orleans (Quick Answer)
Based on diner recommendations across 3 restaurants:
- Commander's Palace, $55.00 (Garden District)
- Mr. John's Steakhouse — 94% recommended, $52.00 (Garden District)
- Mr. John's Steakhouse — 92% recommended, $54.00 (Garden District)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 3 Restaurants Compared
#1
Commander's Palace
Garden District·$$$$
Chargrilled Creekstone Farms Beef Tenderloin
$55.00
Prime beef tenderloin cooked on an open flame, served with sides à la carte.
Tip: Add Freddie mac and cheese with andouille sausage and crawfish — it's a signature side that elevates the steak.
#294% recommend
Mr. John's Steakhouse
Garden District·$$$$
Filet Mignon
$52.00
USDA Prime beef tenderloin broiled at high heat and finished with melted butter.
Tip: Order the filet mignon. It's why the restaurant exists and why you should go.
#392% recommend
Mr. John's Steakhouse
Garden District·$$$$
NY Strip Steak
$54.00
USDA Prime New York strip with a dark crust, served on a sizzling plate.
Tip: If you've ordered the filet at other steakhouses, try the strip here — it's refined by the broiling technique.