Where is the best pie in New Orleans?

Based on diner recommendations, the best pie in New Orleans is at Brigtsen's. We compared 3 restaurants serving pie.

How much does pie cost in New Orleans?

Pie prices in New Orleans range from $9.00 to $19.00 across 3 restaurants.

3 restaurants compared

Price range: $9.00 – $19.00

Avg recommendation: 89%

Based on diner recommendations across 3 restaurants:

Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.

Riverbend·$$$

Pecan Pie with Caramel Sauce

$9.00

Buttery pie crust filled with pecans, brown sugar, and eggs, served warm with caramel.

Tip: Order this warm — ask the kitchen to heat it if it's been sitting. The butter crust is best eaten warm.

#289% recommend

Uptown·$$$

Lemon Ice Box Pie

$11.00

Classic tart lemon pie in a graham cracker crust with whipped cream.

Tip: This is a reliable choice if you're unsure about other desserts on the menu — it hasn't changed in decades for good reason.

#388% recommend

Lower Garden District·$$

Oyster Pie

$19.00

Oysters in a savory pie crust with a creamy, herb-forward filling.

Tip: Ask if the oyster pie is available before you visit — it's a special that doesn't appear every day.