Best Potatoes in Chicago
4 restaurants compared
Price range: $4.25 – $14.00
Avg recommendation: 88%
Top 4 Potatoes in Chicago (Quick Answer)
Our editors' picks across 4 restaurants:
- Gene & Georgetti — score 91/100, $14.00 (River North)
- Lou Mitchell's — score 90/100, $4.25 (West Loop)
- Au Cheval — score 88/100, $14.00 (West Loop)
- Au Cheval — score 82/100, $8.00 (West Loop)
Scroll down for detailed comparisons, prices, and diner tips for each restaurant.
All 4 Restaurants Compared
#1Score 91/100
Gene & Georgetti
River North·$$$$
Vesuvio Potatoes
$14.00
Crispy fried potatoes with garlic, parsley, and herbs, served family-style.
Tip: Order two portions of Vesuvio potatoes — one per every two people at the table.
#2Score 90/100
Lou Mitchell's
West Loop·$
Hash Brown Potatoes
$4.25
Crispy, golden hash browns made to order.
Tip: Double order the hash browns and ask for them extra crispy. They're the standout side and worth the extra investment.
#3Score 88/100
Au Cheval
West Loop·$$
Crispy Hash with Duck Heart Gravy
$14.00
Crispy potato hash topped with duck heart gravy and a fried egg.
Tip: Order this on Saturday or Sunday morning — it pairs with strong cocktails.
#4Score 82/100
Au Cheval
West Loop·$$
Cheese Fries
$8.00
Thick-cut fries topped with melted American cheese and beer gravy.
Tip: A good side to pair with the burger, or order on its own as a snack.